Piano Playing Reduces Stress More Than Other Creative Art Activities

Journal

International Journal of Music Education

Year

2011

Volume

29

Issue

3

First Page

257

Last Page

263

Abstract

Few studies have been conducted on the physiological effects of creative art activities. In this study, the effects of creative art activities on human stress were investigated, and their effects were compared in 57 healthy college students (27 males and 30 females). Subjects were divided into four groups, each of which participated in 30-minute sessions of one of the following creative activities or a control activity: (1) playing the piano; (2) molding a piece of clay; (3) calligraphy (writing using a brush and ink); and (4) remaining silent (as a control activity). Cortisol levels and the State-trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI-I) were measured before and after each session. Post-session cortisol levels were markedly decreased for piano playing, clay molding and calligraphy, indicating a reduction in stress due to participation in creative activities; the effect of piano playing was significantly greater than clay molding and calligraphy. Post-session STAI scores decreased significantly in all groups other than the control group, indicating a reduction in anxiety induced by engaging in creative activities. The psychological and physiological stress-reducing effects of creative activity, particularly playing the piano, were demonstrated. In addition, the role of music education in school in mental health is discussed.

Music and Health Institute Terms

Anxiety Scales; Cortisol Levels; Mental Health; Playing an Instrument; Psychological Outcomes; Stress; Stress Hormone Levels

Indexed Terms

creative art activities; piano playing; purpose of music education; stress; Physiology; Hormones; Trait anxiety; Stress management; Activities; Cortisol; Mental health; Piano music; Comparative analysis; College students; Calligraphy; Anxiety

Study Type

Randomized Controlled; Trial; Quantitative Methods

Disciplines

Psychiatric and Mental Health

Document Type

Article

More Info

Share

COinS